Home » The Picture Play

Alexander Black’s Pre-Film Picture Play

“…simply the art of the tableau vivant plus the science of photography”

-Alexander Black, “Photography in Fiction: Miss Jerry, the First Picture Play”, Scribner’s Magazine 1895

On October 9 1894, a crowd gathered at the Carbon Studios in Manhattan for something a little different: The front of the room was draped with a screen, a magic lantern at the back of the house. The evening’s entertainment was a picture play, neither a live play nor a true motion picture, but something in the space in between. The picture play was Alexander Black’s attempt to present a play without live actors, projected on a screen with the illusion of motion created by the use of a dissolving magic lantern, accompanied by a narrated script to tell the story.

Black had been inspired by earlier magic lantern presentations he had given in front of audiences, when he noticed the natural ease with which members of the audience constructed imagined narratives to go with his photos. He created the picture play over the course of the previous summer, photographing over 200 individual stills of carefully posed motion in his studios in Manhattan, with a few images shot on location around New York City, all developed on glass plate lantern slides.

Miss Jerry told the stories of the adventures and romances of Jerry, a girl reporter in the big city, possibly inspired by Alexander’s wife, Elizabeth, who had spent her early years working in newsrooms.

The significance of the picture play was less in the technical innovation of the four-slides-per-minute motion effect, but more in the vision of presenting a full length feature in front of an audience in a permanent medium that could travel, long before Edison, the Lumiere brothers, and the other cinema creators thought to move beyond small format peep-show style contraptions and short format glimpses of motion.

Three complete picture plays were produced in all: Miss Jerry (1894), A Capital Courtship (1896) and The Girl and the Guardsman (1899). Black traveled extensively with his picture plays, presenting them to audiences around the United States. 

After his death, Black’s scripts and original sets of glass slides were donated to the New York Municipal Archives, which transferred materials to the Brander Matthews collection at Columbia University in 1949. This collection was dispersed some time later, and it is unclear where some of the materials ended up. A surviving selection of slides is kept in the collections at Princeton University, and in the private collections of the Black family, but sadly, no complete picture play is known to have survived. Other papers related to Alexander Blacks’s career both as a pre-cinema innovator and as an author and editor are kept at St. Lawrence University and the New York Public Library special collections. 

Miss Jerry gun scene

“When I outlined my plan to certain writers and artists, the response was unanimously discouraging. A typical warning came from J. Wells Champney. Champney was one of the painters who took a real interest in photography. He had persuaded me to speak on photography and art at the National Academy. He brought about the presentation of the same exposition before New York’s leading photographic society. But photographed fiction — that’s what he saw as impossible. “Why,” he said, “you know how stiff a photographed group looks. Imagine a succession of these! No, it can’t be done.”

As an incentive this decision was perfect. A sympathetic prophesy of failure prodded me into proving that the prophet was wrong.”

-Alexander Black,  Time and Chance; Adventures with People and Print

A Million and One Nights

“While the motion picture was progressing with mincing steps in the peep show Edison Kinetoscope the sheer force of the evolution of expression presented the world with an interesting paradox – the birth of the photoplay upon the screen. . . Black arrived at a rate of four slides a minute for his presentation…”

– A Million and One Nights, A Million and One Nights: The History of the Motion Picture, Terry Ramsaye

Full Text

Pacific Film Archives Alexander Black

“Who invented the cinema? Was it Thomas Edison or the Lumière brothers? Were motion pictures born when Eadweard Muybridge famously photographed Leland Stanford’s horse in Palo Alto in 1877? One important contender for the title of film forefather, often overlooked today, is Alexander Black. At a time when most films lasted only a few moments, Black toured the turn-of-the-century United States with his multi-act “picture plays.” These live screen performances combined the spoken word with projected magic lantern slides, which Black carefully calibrated to suggest movement as he dissolved from one slide to the next. Black’s work with motion picture technologies conveys the passion of a lifelong experimenter. “

—Kaveh Askari,  “Alexander Black, Film Pioneer” BAMFA/Pacific Film Archives: Article | PDF of program from 2009 screening 

Miss Jerry Harpers Weekly

“At the dawn of the moving image, there was a plethora of initiatives that sought to reproduce reality in images. In 1894, one year before the Lumière brothers patented their cinematograph, the journalist, photographer and writer Alexander Black developed the picture play system. This fused images together to create a new form of audiovisual narration with which he aspired to create “an illusion of reality”. He refined the expressive capacities of existing photography to try to recreate what the first attempts to reproduce moving images could not achieve, namely, to tell complete stories using images. For his first work he chose to relate the tribulations of a young journalist: Miss Jerry. In the formative period of the cinema, Black’s contribution – midway between photography and cinema – had no influence at all on the technical development of the new medium; it was, however, an elaborate antecedent of the construction of visual narratives and his success showed that the public was prepared to welcome cinematographic stories. The image of journalism provided by Miss Jerry also anticipated one of the most solid stereotypes of the woman-journalist in the cinema, known as the sob-sister.”

-Peña-Fernández, Simón & Lazkano-Arrillaga, Iñaki. “Alexander Black’s Miss Jerry (1894). A journalist in the prehistory of cinema.” Comunicacion y Sociedad.  (2017). Researchgate 

Related Resources: The Picture Play & Cinema History

Alexander Black and the Art of the Picture Play, Dr. Kaveh Askari, The new magic lantern journal: volume 9 number 5 (Winter 2003), pp.67-70 (PDF)

Making Movies into Art: Picture Craft from the Magic Lantern to Early Hollywood, Dr. Kaveh Askari, Bloomsbury Publishing | Amazon.com

2009 Screening of Alexander Black films at BAMPFA/Pacific Film Archives, Berkeley CA: Article by Dr. Kaveh Askari | Program PDF

Alexander Black’s Miss Jerry (1894). A journalist in the prehistory of cinema. Peña-Fernández, Simón & Lazkano-Arrillaga, Iñaki. (2017). Comunicacion y Sociedad. (ResearchGate)

The Story and the Screen: Alexander Black’s Picture Play and the Pre-History of the Cinema, Ralf Remshardt, The Princeton University Chronicle, 2004

The First Picture Show: Alexander Black’s “Miss Jerry”, Dick Johnson, Journal of American Culture,Winter 1980 (Wiley online library)

Who’s Who of Victorian Cinema: Alexander Black

Eccentricities of genius; memories of famous men and women of the platform and stage
by Pond, James Burton, 1900, pages 512-513 (Archive.org)

Engines of our Ingenuity: Riding the Wrong Horse, by John H. Lienhard

Essential Films: Alexander Black | Miss Jerry

 “Alexander Black’s Picture Plays: 1893-1894.” Burnes Hollyman and Alexander Black., Cinema Journal 16, no. 2 (1977): 26-33. (Jstor listing)